• Home
  • Executive Benefits
    • Supplemental Executive Retirement Plans – SERP
    • Split Dollar Loans
    • Deferral Plans
    • Welfare Plans
  • Revenue Strategies
    • Bank/Business Owned Life Insurance – BOLI
    • Corporate Owned Life Insurance – COLI
    • Insurance Company Owned Life Insurance
    • Managed Accounts
    • Guaranteed Income Contracts
    • Fee Income Strategies
  • Asset Protection
    • Estate Planning
    • Business Succession Planning
    • Key Person Planning
  • About
    • R. Scott Richardson, JD
    • Bruce F. Barge
    • Brenda R. Haag
    • Chris A. Richardson
    • Debra Hardimon
    • Fannie Mae Pantaleon
    • Gary Wilberg
    • Jeff Prescher
    • Joe Tripalin
    • Jonathan Barnes
    • Patrick J. Costello
    • Philip Aderton
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Events >
      • Webinar-Checking Accounts?
      • History – Calendars by Year >
        • Client Conference 2017
        • Client Conference 2015
    • Video Education
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Executive Benefits
    • Supplemental Executive Retirement Plans – SERP
    • Split Dollar Loans
    • Deferral Plans
    • Welfare Plans
  • Revenue Strategies
    • Bank/Business Owned Life Insurance – BOLI
    • Corporate Owned Life Insurance – COLI
    • Insurance Company Owned Life Insurance
    • Managed Accounts
    • Guaranteed Income Contracts
    • Fee Income Strategies
  • Asset Protection
    • Estate Planning
    • Business Succession Planning
    • Key Person Planning
  • About
    • R. Scott Richardson, JD
    • Bruce F. Barge
    • Brenda R. Haag
    • Chris A. Richardson
    • Debra Hardimon
    • Fannie Mae Pantaleon
    • Gary Wilberg
    • Jeff Prescher
    • Joe Tripalin
    • Jonathan Barnes
    • Patrick J. Costello
    • Philip Aderton
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Events >
      • Webinar-Checking Accounts?
      • History – Calendars by Year >
        • Client Conference 2017
        • Client Conference 2015
    • Video Education
  • Contact
IZALE Financial Group

Blog

Court Rules Proceeds of Key Person Life Policy Owed to Business After Employee's Retirement

1/9/2016

0 Comments

 
TOPIC:  Court Rules Proceeds of Key Person Life Policy Owed to Business After Employee’s Retirement

CITATION:  Continental Assurance Company v. Cole Frago, No. 3:14-CV-01364(VLB) (U.S.D.C. CT Dec. 2, 2015).
 
SUMMARY:  The widow of a former employee of a business entity called Cole Frago brought suit in the Federal District Court of Connecticut, seeking to recover the death proceeds of a life policy originally purchased as key employee coverage. 
 
Cole Frago asserted that it never transferred the key employee coverage to the insured, nor did it have any obligation to do so, and the death proceeds were properly paid to the company.  The insured’s widow countered that the parties’ written agreement obligated Cole Frago to offer to sell the policy to the insured at his retirement, and no such offer was ever made.
 
The court granted summary judgment to Cole Frago, allowing it to keep the policy’s death benefit.

RELEVANCE: There is no doubt that key person life insurance is intended to protect the business against the premature death of a key employee.  It also is clear that, in the absence of an agreement to the contrary, the employer has the option to continue the coverage - even after the key employee terminates employment.
 
But what happens if there is ambiguity over the parties’ intentions about their rights and obligations when the employment relationship ends?  What if the employer and employee discussed the possibility of a policy transfer at some point in the future, but never committed to an actual agreement to do so and set nothing down in writing?
 
The Cole Frago decision underscores the idea that it is the policy owner, not the insured, who controls all the ownership rights—including the right to name the beneficiary of the life policy.  In the absence of an explicit agreement (preferably in writing), the policy owner’s control will continue even after the relationship between the parties changes (in this case, termination of the insured’s employment by the policy owner).
 
FACTS:  Cole, Frago, Cusick, Chestler & Co. LLC, an accounting partnership, incorporated as a limited liability company on January 1, 1994. At the time of incorporation, the partners, who became members of the company, were Frank Frago, Stanley L. Cusick Edward Chestler, James Cohen and Richard Guerriere.
 
The company purchased and maintained “key man” life insurance policies on the lives of each of its members, including the decedent Stanley L. Cusick. In fact, Cole Frago purchased two separate policies insuring the life of Stanley L. Cusick; the first policy was purchased from Continental in 1993 and had a $100,000 face value and the second policy was purchased from Jackson National with a $300,000 face value.  Cole Frago was the owner and the beneficiary of both policies.
 
Stanley Cusick retired at the end of 1996 and entered into a retirement agreement with Cole Frago. Under the terms of the agreement, Cusick assigned to Cole Frago all “right, title, and interest” in the company in exchange for a lump sum retirement payment of $436,340 that was to be paid over the course of ten years until 2006.
 
The retirement agreement also provided that Cole Frago could, at its discretion, continue to pay for and maintain both the policies on Cusick’s life:
 
The Company shall continue to pay for and maintain the life insurance policies owned by the Company which insure Cusick until December 31, 1996. The Company shall have the option to continue to pay for and maintain such policy or policies after such date.

If the Company does not desire to continue to pay for and maintain any such policy, the Company shall give Cusick prior written notice and the opportunity to purchase such policy.
 
After Cusick’s retirement, Cole Frago maintained and paid for both policies; however, on November 1, 1997, the three remaining members of Cole Frago, defendants Guerriere, Cohen, and Chestler, merged their company with another accounting firm, Blum Shapiro and Co., P.C.  Under the terms of the merger, Blum Shapiro agreed to assume the obligation to pay the remainder of Cusick’s retirement benefit payments through 2006. Blum Shapiro also provided Cusick’s medical insurance benefits from 2000 through 2005.
 
From 1997 through 2006, Blum Shapiro issued the checks that were used to pay the premiums for both of the life policies insuring Cusick. After 2006, Guerriere, on behalf of Cole Frago and its members, began paying the policy premiums directly.
 
In 2003, Guerriere filed articles of dissolution with the Connecticut Secretary of State on behalf of Cole Frago. Cole Frago elected not to liquidate or transfer any of the policies to effect a wind up, instead maintaining ownership of the policies until the eventual death of Cusick. 
 
After the death of Cusick in 2014, the company and Cusick’s widow--the executor of his estate--submitted competing claims for payment of the death benefit proceeds. Both life carriers filed similar interpleader suits against Cole Frago and Cusick’s executor.
 
Cusick’s executor argued that because of Cole Frago’s dissolution as an entity in 2003, Cole Frago effectively chose to divest itself of its assets—including the insurance policies on Cusick.  Since the company dissolution was arguably a liquidation of assets, the executor posited that the policies should have been offered to Cusick under the 1996 retirement agreement.
 
The court disagreed.  It noted that even though Cole Frago had submitted paperwork for dissolution in 2003, it had not yet completely terminated operations even as late as the date of the court case.  Furthermore, it ruled that simply filing articles of dissolution does not mean a company is immediately liquidating its assets.  Winding up a company and its assets takes time, and in this case Cole Frago had simply not yet gotten around to dealing with the policy on Cusick’s life.  Therefore, because Cole Frago still effectively existed, it had not violated the retirement agreement—and therefore it was entitled to the death benefit.


DISCLAIMER
This information is intended solely for information and education and is not intended for use as legal or tax advice. Reference herein to any specific tax or other planning strategy, process, product or service does not constitute promotion, endorsement or recommendation by AALU. Persons should consult with their own legal or tax advisors for specific legal or tax advice.

Click to download the printable pdf.
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    IZALE Financial Group

    As an independent firm, we’re driven by close client relationships. For you, that means that our technical expertise is yours to rely on. 

    RSS Feed

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    April 2018
    March 2018
    November 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    March 2015
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013

    Categories

    All
    1035 Tax Deferred Exchange
    2018
    401K
    457f Plans
    AALU
    Articles
    Asset Management
    Asset Protection
    BalancedComp
    Bank
    Banking
    Bank Owned Life Insurance
    Bankruptcy
    Basel III
    Beneficiary
    Benefit Plans
    Benefits
    Board Of Directors
    BOL
    BOLI
    Business Owned Life Insurance
    Capital Conservation Buffer
    Capital Management
    Capital Requirements
    CBAI
    CDI
    CEO
    CFO
    Chris Richardson
    Clawback
    Cole Frago
    COLI
    Common Equity
    Commuity Bank Of Trenton
    Community Banking
    Community Banks
    Compensation
    Connecticut Court
    Consumer Protection Act
    Consumer Protection Act Of 2010
    Corporate Owned Life Insurance
    Corporate Taxation
    CPA
    Credit Union
    Credit Union Magazine
    Credit Union National Association
    Credit Unions
    CUES
    CUNA
    DBO
    Death Benefits
    Divorce
    Dodd Frank Wall Street Reform
    Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform
    Employee Benefits
    ERISA
    Estate Planning
    Estate Tax
    Estate Trust
    Executive Benefits
    Executive Compensation
    Executive Retirement Plans
    Family Legacy
    FDIC
    Fee Income Strategies
    FICA
    Finance Industry
    Financial Education
    Financial Executives
    Financial Managers Society
    Finanical Reporting
    Fiscal Year 2015
    FL
    FMS
    FMStv
    FRS
    Gary Wilberg
    Gerald H. Sherman
    Gift Tax
    Greenberg Traurig
    Greene V. Commissioner
    House Ways And Means
    Incentive Based Compensation
    Incentive-based Compensation
    Income Tax
    Inherit
    Inheritance
    In-Laws
    Insurance
    Insurance Premium
    Insurance Tax Liability
    IRA
    IRC
    Irrevocable Trust
    IRS
    IZALE
    IZALE Financial Group
    IZALE Testimonial
    JB Barnes
    Jobs Act 2017
    Joe Tripalin
    Jonathan Barnes
    Jonathan M. Forster
    Ken Kies
    Key Person Life Policy
    Las Vegas
    Leadership
    Legacy Planning
    Life Insurance
    Life Policy
    LLP
    Martin Kalb
    Media
    National Credit Union Administration
    NCUA
    Non-profit
    Nonqualified Deferred Compensation
    Nonqualified Plans
    Obama Administration
    Orlando
    Pay Ratio Rule
    Phil Aderton
    Philip Aderton
    Premarital Planning
    President Obama
    President's Budget
    Press
    Press Releases
    Profit Sharing
    PRS
    Rebecca Manicone
    Regulationry Issues
    Regulatory Capital Calculation
    Regulatory Environments
    Resources
    Retirement
    Retirement Plan
    Richard A. Sirus
    Risk Management
    Roth
    R. Scott Richardson
    SBLI Term Life Insurance
    Scott Richardson
    SEC
    SERP
    Small Business Resale
    Social Security Tax
    Split Dollar Plans
    Steve Fichtenbaum
    Steven B. Lapidus
    Stock Exchange
    Stuart Lewis
    Tax Benefit
    Tax Code
    Tax Court
    Tax Cuts
    Tax Cuts And Jobs Act Of 2017
    Tax Deductions
    Tax Deferred Assets
    Tax Incentives
    Tax Law
    Tax Liabilities
    Tax Planning
    Tax Refor
    Tax Reform
    TCJA 2017
    The Forum
    Trust
    Trustee
    Trusts
    US Supreme Court
    Washington Report
    Webinars
    Webinar W.O.W.S.
    WRMarketplace
    WRNewswire

Client Log-In

Log in to Pangburn
Log in to rBOLI.com

Contact

 855-492-5334 | Contact
Join Our Mailing List
© 2011 - 2018 IZALE Financial Group. All rights reserved. Login.
​Effective June 9, 2017, all individuals who provide advice to retirement plans, including Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), must abide by the fiduciary standard.  What does the fiduciary standard mean?  This means that your advisor must put your interests first before their own or that of the firm, make prudent recommendations, charge reasonable compensation and make no misrepresentations to you regarding recommended investments.  The recommendations made by your advisor must be based upon your specific investment needs and objectives.  The fiduciary standard is applicable to any recommendations that your advisor makes to you, the client, for your retirement account. 

Please note the firm does have policies and procedures in place to monitor this level of fiduciary responsibility for our clients.
This site is published for residents of the United States only. Representatives may only conduct business with residents of the states and jurisdictions in which they are properly registered. Therefore, a response to a request for information may be delayed until appropriate registration is obtained or exemption from registration is determined. Not all of services referenced on this site are available in every state and through every advisor listed. For additional information, please contact Scott Richardson at 855-492-5334 .
✕